0% APR or cash back?
Updated 2026-11-17
Take the cash back when the rebate is bigger than the break-even rebate, and take 0% when it's smaller. The break-even depends on two things: the rate you'd pay on your own loan and how long the loan runs.
Most automakers make you pick one. You either finance through their lender at 0%, or you give up the special rate, take the cash off the price, and finance the rest somewhere else at a normal rate. The question is which choice leaves you paying less.
A worked example
Say you've negotiated a $35,000 price and have no down payment. The automaker offers 0% for 60 months or $3,000 cash back. Your credit union quotes 6.35% for 60 months, which is about the average new-car rate Experian reported for the second quarter of 2026.
| 0% for 60 months | $3,000 back, 6.35% for 60 months | |
|---|---|---|
| Amount financed | $35,000 | $32,000 |
| Monthly payment | $583.33 | $623.87 |
| Total you pay | $35,000 | $37,432 |
| Interest | $0 | $5,432 |
The rebate cuts $3,000 off the loan, and then 6.35% interest adds $5,432 back. The 0% offer wins by $2,432.
Try these numbers in the calculator
The break-even rebate
For this car and this loan, the break-even rebate is $5,079. A rebate of exactly that size makes the two offers cost the same. Below it, 0% is cheaper. Above it, the cash back is cheaper.
Here's how the gap moves as the rebate grows, same car, same 6.35% loan:
| Rebate | Payment on your loan | Total you pay | Which wins |
|---|---|---|---|
| $2,000 | $643.37 | $38,602 | 0% by $3,602 |
| $3,000 | $623.87 | $37,432 | 0% by $2,432 |
| $4,000 | $604.37 | $36,262 | 0% by $1,262 |
| $6,000 | $565.38 | $33,923 | Rebate by $1,077 |
The break-even rises with your loan rate, because a pricier loan eats more of the rebate. On the same $35,000, 60-month deal:
| Your loan APR | Break-even rebate |
|---|---|
| 4.41% | $3,642 |
| 6.35% | $5,079 |
| 9.71% | $7,360 |
Those three rates are Experian's Q2 2026 averages for super-prime, prime and near-prime new-car borrowers. Bankrate notes it's nearly impossible to get 0% without excellent credit, so the top row is the one most 0% shoppers will face. That's also why it pays to get a real quote from your bank or credit union before you walk in. A strong outside rate is what makes cash back competitive.
A closer call from this month's offers
Nissan's Rogue is on this month's list at 0% for 60 months or $4,500 cash back, with a starting price of $33,056. At a 6.35% outside loan:
| 0% for 60 months | $4,500 back, 6.35% for 60 months | |
|---|---|---|
| Monthly payment | $550.93 | $556.73 |
| Total you pay | $33,056 | $33,404 |
The break-even is $4,797, so the $4,500 rebate falls just short and 0% wins by $348. Knock your loan rate down a point and the answer flips. Close calls like this are where running your own numbers matters. You can see every brand's current offers on the deals page.
Does inflation change the winner?
With equal terms, no. This surprises people, so it's worth spelling out.
A dollar you pay in five years is worth less than one you pay today. Prices rise, so each future payment buys less, and you're effectively paying it back in cheaper money. The calculator puts every payment into today's dollars for that reason.
In the example above, at 3% inflation, the 0% loan's 60 payments are worth $32,464 in today's dollars and the rebate loan's are worth $34,720. Both shrink, and the 0% offer still wins, now by $2,256 instead of $2,432. At 5% inflation it still wins, by $2,148.
The reason is simple. Both options are level monthly payments over the same 60 months. Inflation shrinks month 1 by the same proportion on both loans, month 30 by the same proportion on both, and so on. The bigger total stays bigger. The gap gets a little smaller in today's dollars, but it never changes sign. The break-even rebate stays at $5,079 whatever inflation rate you pick.
So if both loans run the same number of months, you can ignore inflation for the decision itself. It only tells you that the whole car costs a bit less than the sticker suggests, because you pay most of it later.
When inflation does change the answer
It matters when the two options put your money out the door on different schedules.
The first case is different terms. If the 0% offer is for 36 months and you'd take the rebate over 72, the 0% buyer pays faster in fuller dollars while the rebate buyer stretches payments into years when each dollar is worth less. Inflation can flip the winner there. We walk through that case in 0% for 36 months or the rebate over 72?.
The second is paying cash. Cash today against payments spread over five years is a real trade between dollars now and dollars later, and the rate you use decides it. See Should you pay cash or take 0% financing?.
The third is a down payment or trade-in that differs between options. Money you hand over today doesn't shrink, so the option that front-loads more cash looks worse in today's dollars.
Things that tilt the comparison
Some brands let you stack a smaller "bonus cash" with the special APR. In that case, enter only the rebate you'd actually give up. A few offers on this month's list are like this.
Sales tax is often charged on the price before the rebate, so the rebate may not lower your tax. That's the same on both sides, so it doesn't change the winner unless you finance the tax.
Paying a loan off early helps the higher-rate loan more than the 0% one. If you plan to pay off the rebate loan in two years, the rebate looks better than the table above shows.
And 0% offers usually come through the automaker's own finance company with top-tier credit required. If you don't qualify, the comparison is moot. Our guide to whether 0% is really free covers the other catches.
Run your own numbers
Use your negotiated price, your actual loan quote, and the rebate the dealer says you'd give up. The calculator shows the winner, the gap in today's dollars, and the break-even rebate for your deal.
Try these numbers in the calculator
This is general information, not financial advice.